| |
|
 |
|
Can there be a more
melancholy place in all East Anglia than
Pakefield cliffs? I sat outside the Jolly
Sailors public house, nursing my pint of
Adnams and gazing out at them. A footpath
runs along the top leading from the pub
to the church, with benches set along it
so you can gaze out to sea in that way we
English like to do. But there is nothing
attractive about the cliffs: they look
more like a grassed-over landslip than
anything that you'd expect to find at the
coast, and the streets which lead down to
them seem to have been hacked off at the
limbs. In fact, that is precisely what
has happened. All along this coast, for
centuries, communities have suffered from
the voracious appetite of the sea. But at
the start of the 20th century, a new pier
was built to the south of Lowestoft
docks. It altered the movement of the
tides to such an extent that, over the
next 30 years, Pakefield lost more than
400 houses to the sea, along with many
lives. The churchyard of All Saints and
St Margaret, which now stands
precipitously above the beach, was then
more than half a mile from the waves'
reach. Look at it now; only time and a
fragile sea wall separate this church
from its watery destiny. I'm
sorry to keep going on about it, but
isn't Lowestoft a strange place! It
straggles and billows relentlessly for
four miles down the coast from far off
Corton, until it finally peters out in
this churchyard. It has some of the
grandest and most fascinating
architecture in Suffolk, along with some
of the ugliest, bleakest and most
derelict. The people are the friendliest
in England, and are fiercely independent,
supporting Norwich City rather than
Ipswich Town, but treating their Norfolk
cousins over the border in Great Yarmouth
with a decided contempt. Lowestoft docks
is the dismal, chaotic heart of this
shapeless sprawl that is home to not far
short of a hundred thousand people now.
To the rest of Suffolk, Lowestoftians are
like Kerrymen to the Irish or Belgians to
the French; So like the rest of us; and
yet, somehow... not quite.
|
And
of all Lowestoft, Pakefield is the strangest
place. Mind you, All Saints and St Margaret has
done pretty well to last as long as it has. Until
the 1930s, Pakefield Parish Council clung
stubbornly on to its independence, refusing to be
incorporated into Lowestoft Borough despite the
fait accompli that the sprawling suburb of
Kirkley had presented it with. The provision of
sea defences bankrupted the village, and still
the sea took their houses. Eventually, they gave
up in despair, and surrendered themselves to
urban living. The financial muscle of the Borough
became responsible for holding the line.
If
you had come here then, you would have seen a
great rarity. This church had the only surviving
intact Lenten veil pulley in all England, with
wheels and everything; a 15th century device for
drawing the Lenten curtain across the sanctuary,
still servicable after half a Millenium. Having
read about it in Munro Cautley's 1937 Suffolk
Churches and their Treasures, I hastened up
here to see it. But there was something I did not
know about Pakefield. On a night in April 1941
Lowestoft suffered a serious bombing raid. All
Saints and St Margaret sustained a direct hit,
and was completely gutted. The pulley was
destroyed. After the war, plans were drawn up by
the Diocese of Norwich to abandon the church, and
replace it with a modern church further inland.
Sensible plans, perhaps, and I'm not sure why
they were dropped. But instead, it was restored,
and a completely new interior built within the
shell of the old church.
This
is just as well for us, for there is something
fascinating about All Saints and St Margaret that
I have not mentioned. In fact, it is two
churches, side by side, the parish churches of
what, until the 18th century, were two separate
parishes. The easternmost of these former
parishes has now been completely taken by the
sea. It may seem strange to us that these two
naves, separated only by an open arcade, could
have carried on their business like this. But it
wasn't that unusual. Several other Suffolk
churches were shared by two parishes; at
Horringer for instance, where there was a chapel
for the hamlet of Horsecroft, which served as
their parish church. In other places, different
parish churches shared the same churchyard.
And
in any case, any large medieval church would
often have had several Masses going on at the
same time; the fact that they might be for
different parishes would have been irrelevant. In
addition, the laity going about their devotions
in the nave, offering up prayers, saying the
rosary, and so on, would have provided a jolly
cacophony in any church. The problems only arose
with the triumph of Protestantism and the
creation of the Church of England in the 16th
century. With the shift to a congregational
liturgy based on the ministry of the Word, with
lengthy sermons from ministers who were preachers
rather than priests, concurrent services could
only be a disturbance. In fact, they became a
downright nuisance.The parishes solved the
problem by bricking up the arcade - not
unreasonably, perhaps. When the two parishes were
merged in 1743, this was opened up to provide a
large church to serve the lot of them.
As
you will know, most East Anglian medieval
churches are open all day every day, and those
that are not have a notice telling you where to
get the key. But I first came to Pakefield about
ten years ago, in the days when the church was
kept locked without a keyholder notice, and so I
had not yet seen inside. At that time, all the
Lowestoft churches were kept locked - as, indeed,
most of them are today. However, in the years
since, I had been told that Pakefield church had
been left bravely open to passing pilgrims and
strangers. This was excellent news, and I kept
planning to get on a train and take a look. But
the wheel has now turned full circle, because
today this church is kept locked again, although
there is at least a keyholder notice now. In any
event, I came here on Historic Churches Bike Ride
day 2009, and so it was fairly easy to get inside
- well, relatively so. Suitably refreshed by Mr
Adnam and his ales, I wheeled my bike along the
clifftop path. But the fence that ran along the
eastern side of the graveyard allowed no access
to the church, and neither did the fence up the
southern side. In fact, I had to go almost
completely around the church before I could enter
the graveyard from the little square which sits
to the north of it. This gave me a chance to see
the building from all sides of course. The
thatching on the south nave is very attractive,
and you can see the herring-bone brickwork which
Mortlock thought might be a sign of the
building's Saxon origins.
You
enter through the north porch into a building
which has a pleasingly well-used feel to it,
although inevitably very little of the atmosphere
we have come to expect from entering a medieval
building. For obvious reasons again there is very
little Victorian glass, a refreshing change after
the other medieval churches in the area, and some
of what glass there is is very good, an
intriguing 1961 window by Andrew Anderson in
memory of Elizabeth Graham Hunt, who was the
founder of the Pakefield Mothers Union. The
use of brown in the glass is very unusual, and
the relationship of grandmother, young mother and
son is reminiscent of medieval and continental
images of St Anne with the blessed Virgin and
Christchild. The image of Christ as the Good
Shepherd by HJ Salisbury in the glass of the
south nave chancel is frankly hideous, though.
The wooden-faced Christ holds the lamb as though
it were a ventriloquist's dummy. It was installed
to celebrate the protestant and evangelical
ministry of a 19th Century Rector,
presumably in reaction to the Anglo-catholic
shenanigans up the road at Kirkley. There is also
a scattering of fragments of surviving medieval
and continental glass in some of the upper
lights.
Mounted
on the wall is a set of brasses to John and Agnes
Bowf, which is of interest because, dating from
1417, it is the earliest civilian brass in
Suffolk. It is not in terribly good condition,
but the fact that it survived at all is a
testimony to the fact that it was mounted on the
floor at the time of the German bombing. If there
was a fire at Pakefield today it would run away
like melting butter. But, as at nearby
Kessingland, the greatest treasure here is the
font. It is a late 14th century piece in
unusually good condition, deeply cut and
crocketted like the fonts you often find in
Norfolk broadland parishes. It sits proudly
beneath the arcade at the west end serving both
naves, which are filled with modern chairs. All
in all, I thought that this was a pleasing
church, if not an exciting one.
| Signing the Historic
Churches Bike Ride form at the welcoming
desk, I couldn't resist asking the lady
on duty why the church was now kept
locked. Was it just the Lowestoft effect? "Well,
we had a break-in", said the lady.
"And someone threw stones at the
Mothers Union window."
From inside the
church, I wondered? But of course not,
said the lady, looking at me as if I was
stupid. I went into my usual spiel about
how insurance companies prefer churches
to be open during the day, because this
reduces the risk of both thefts and
break-ins, and - but she put up her hand
to stop me. "We have to
keep the church locked", she
insisted. "There are drug addicts
sleeping rough on the beach, and they
used to come into the church and steal
the poppy money", which told me
something else I didn't know about
Pakefield, and probably everything I
needed to know about how Pakefield
Anglican Parish perceived its Christian
mission. Apologising profusely for my
insolence, I headed off on my bike,
looking back at the church as it sat
nervously on the cliff-edge. Beyond it,
the impatient waves churned, grating the
shingle. If I come back in fifty years,
what will I see then?
|
|
 |
|
|
|